With the constant evolution of hair accessory trends, finding the perfect hair tie for thick hair can be a real struggle. Hair tie enthusiasts are often overwhelmed by the endless options available, each promising to be the best option for your unique hair type.
Whether you’re browsing a blog or wandering a store aisle, the numerous choices between scrunchies and elastic hair ties can spark fierce debates, much like choosing between flats versus heels or silver versus gold.
Taking a closer look at these simple accessories reveals that scrunchies and elastic hair ties serve different needs and preferences.
Scrunchies, made from soft, statement-making fabrics, fasten your hair gently and are often favored for their style and comfort. In contrast, elastic hair ties are the go-to for those needing to hold their ponytails tight, especially during physical activities.
Hairstylists often weigh in on this topic, generally pointing to scrunchies as the clear winner for hair health, especially for those with thick hair that can easily be damaged by tighter options.
Scrunchies or Elastic Hair Ties for Thick Hair? The Short Answer
When choosing between scrunchies and elastic hair ties for thick hair, consider your preferences and hair needs. Scrunchies are softer and less damaging, suitable for daily wear and adding style. Elastic hair ties offer a strong hold, ideal for securing hair during physical activities and achieving a sleek look.Which Factors to Remember While Choosing the Best Hair Tie for Thick Hair?
Desired Hairstyle
When choosing between scrunchies and elastic hair ties, consider the desired hairstyle you want to achieve. Scrunchies are great for looser, more relaxed hairstyles such as messy buns and ponytails, and they even work well as a cute wrist accessory.
They add volume and can be a stylish statement piece. On the other hand, elastic hair ties are better for sleek, tight styles that require a firm hold, like a high ponytail, braids, or styles meant to keep your hair out of your face during workouts.
Daily Activities
For daily activities, choosing between scrunchies and elastic hair ties can depend on your activity level and comfort needs. Scrunchies are a less desirable choice for sports or other strenuous activities where you need to keep your hair off your face; here, elastics typically win out due to their secure hold.
However, for almost all other situations, especially more relaxed settings or even while sleeping, stick with a scrunchie for less stress on your hair and increased comfort.
Keep an Eye on Your Hair Health
When choosing between a scrunchie and an elastic hair tie, consider the current condition of your hair since it should play a role in your decision. Scrunchies, with their fabric covering, act as a buffer that reduces friction and tension, making them generally better for hair health.
They are less likely to cause breakage, particularly important for those with fine, curly, or damaged hair. In contrast, elastic hair ties can be too tight and may snap hair, especially if they have a metal connector. Opt for scrunchies to keep your hair healthy and stylish.
Scrunchies: A Soft and Stylish Choice
Since they were invented in the 1960s and gained widespread popularity during the ’80s and ’90s, scrunchies have seen a remarkable resurgence in recent years. These beloved hair accessories are adored by people of all age groups and are celebrated for their gentle hold on hair.
Scrunchies are created by sewing a soft, stretchy fabric around an elastic band, resulting in a fluffy, gathered, and voluminous hair tie that not only is functional but also adds a stylish flair to any hairdo.
They come in various sizes, materials, colors, and patterns, making them a versatile and fashionable choice for all hair types and personal styles. Whether you prefer small, discreet options or oversized, statement-making ones, there’s a scrunchie for every occasion.
The materials used in crafting these hair ties include cotton, polyester, satin, velvet, and even silk, each offering unique benefits and aesthetic appeal. They apply less direct pressure and friction on the same area of hair, resulting in less damage or breakage.
Better yet, scrunchies can double as playful accessories, adding a pop of color or texture to your hair. For those who love to enhance an updo or even a simple pony, types of scrunchies that incorporate classic bows or other decorations are available.
They look nice, but the silk scrunchies are truly great for your hair; the slippy silk glides over your hair without snagging it, reducing breakage and lost hair while keeping the hair’s moisture and natural oils intact.
Advantages of Using Scrunchies on Thick Hair
- Scrunchies, crafted from soft and smooth materials, provide a gentle grip on thick hair. They create less friction and tension, helping to minimize damage compared to elastic hair ties.
- Scrunchies are very comfortable to wear and do not cause any headaches or scalp discomfort like tight elastic hair ties. You can even be worn at night while sleeping.
- Scrunchies are fun hair accessories that come in a range of styles, like classic velvet or funky prints and patterns. There are plenty of options to choose from, and with embellishments like beads, sequins, or bows, they can add an extra touch of flair to any hairstyle to make your moment special.
- Scrunchies are a better option because they do not create creases in your hair like elastic hair ties. For people who frequently change hairstyles or want to let their hair down after a long day, scrunchies prevent that unsightly dent that traditional hair ties often leave behind.
- Scrunchies are particularly helpful for people with long hair or curly hair. They help reduce hair tangling, especially when made from smooth materials like silk, which has a smooth texture that can significantly reduce friction and prevent knots.
Disadvantages of Using Scrunchies for Thick Hair
- Scrunchies are more costly as compared to traditional hair ties especially when we don’t compromise on the fabric quality making it more costly and less accessible to certain people.
- Scrunchies often come in larger and thicker fabrics occupying more space and are less convenient to carry in a purse, bag, or pocket compared to elastic hair ties. Therefore not the ideal choice more portable and compact hair accessory.
- Scrunchies are made from delicate materials like silk or satin thatwhy not as durable as elastic hair ties. The fabric can easily wear out, fade, or become frayed with prolonged use, and the elastic inside can lose its elasticity over time, affecting the overall performance of the hair accessory.
- Scrunchies are gentle and comfortable to wear, but they are unable to provide the appropriate hold as elastic hair ties give. For people with thick or heavy hair who need a stronghold to keep hair intact, scrunchies may come loose and become messy, especially during strenuous activities.
- Scrunchies can sometimes slip out of smooth or slippery thick hair, especially freshly washed or have a lot of product in it. In these cases, scrunchies need another hair tie with a stronger grip or additional hairpins or clips to keep the hairstyle intact.
Elastic Hair Ties: An Evergreen Accessory
Elastic hair ties, also called hair elastics or ponytail holders, are simple loops of elastic material that hold hair securely in place. These classic and tried-and-true hair accessories have been a staple in people’s hair care arsenal for decades. They come in a variety of sizes, colors, and materials to accommodate different hair types and personal preferences.
Whether made from basic rubber, synthetic materials, or covered with fabric, these elastics provide the right amount of hold. However, they can sometimes cause breakage, so it’s important to look for metal-free bands and choose the right size based on the thickness of your hair.
Advantages of Using Elastic Hair Ties for Thick Hair
- Anyone with thick hair elastic ties provides a stronghold, making them a great choice. During a workout, a long day at work, or other physical activities, it keeps the thickest hair in place ensuring your hairstyle remains intact and secure.
- As compared to Scrunchies elastic hair ties are smaller and less noticeable, for those who prefer a minimalist and discreet look. Offer a sleek and polished look because their low-profile design allows them to blend seamlessly with thicker hair types,
- Elastic hair ties are generally more cost-effective than scrunchies, making them a good budget-friendly option. You can collect a variety of hair ties for different occasions and experiment with different colors, styles, and sizes without being an empty pocket
- They can make uncountable types of hairstyles from simple ponytails to braids, buns, and twists.
- Elastic ties, made from stretchy materials like rubber or silicone, are more durable than scrunchies. They can withstand repeated use and exposure to water or sweat and do not stretch out or lose grip quickly. This durability makes them a long-lasting investment.
Disadvantages of Using Elastic Hair Ties for Thick Hair
- Elastic hair ties can cause potential damage to your hair, especially if they have a tight grip to secure thick hair. This can lead to breakage, split ends, and overall hair weakening, particularly if you wear your hair up frequently.
- For those with a sensitive scalp, elastic ties can be uncomfortable to wear.
- Sometimes, the tight grip and pressure placed on the hair and scalp may lead to pain, discomfort, and even headaches.
- When the hair tie compresses the hair, leaving an indentation that can be difficult to remove, especially if worn in the same position repeatedly create a visible bump or dent in your hair, commonly called a ponytail bump. For those who prefer a smooth, bump-free hairstyle after taking down a ponytail or bun it can be an unwanted, frustrating look.
- Elastic hair ties, become entangled in thick hair because made from rubber or thinner materials. For individuals with twisty hair or coarse thick hair, the issue is problematic as their hair texture is more prone to tangling.
Which One is More Appropriate for Thick Hair?
When deciding between scrunchies and elastic hair ties, both have their pros and cons, but the right choice for thick hair depends on your personal preferences and the specific needs of your hair. Scrunchies are gentle and comfortable, making them a better option for daily use as they are less likely to cause damage thanks to their soft fabric that’s easy on the scalp.
Plus, they’re a great choice if you want a fun accessory to add to your outfit. On the other hand, elastic hair ties are perfect for those needing a stronghold for their thick strands, especially during physical activity like workouts or sports. They are designed to hold hair securely in place, offering a sleek appearance that can give your hairstyle a polished look.
Essential Points to Consider While Choosing a Right Hair Tie?
Summary
Scrunchies and elastic hair ties both have their pros and cons. The best choice depends on your personal preferences and hair type. When selecting a hair tie, consider the appropriate size, tension, and materials to ensure it works effectively for your thick hair without causing damage or discomfort.
While elastic hair ties provide a tighter, secure hold with their rubber band design, scrunchies, made with soft fabrics and gentle elastics, are less likely to pull hair and cause breakage. Hairstylists agree that scrunchies are the better choice for maintaining hair health, but both have their styling strengths and it’s good to switch things up.
Dive into the world of curls with Farah, a celebrated curly hair expert whose passion and expertise have transformed her into a beacon for those seeking to embrace their natural hair texture. With a vibrant career spanning over a decade, Farah has dedicated herself to the science and art of curly hair, making her an authoritative voice in this niche. Her deep understanding of curly hair’s unique needs and challenges allows her to craft personalized care routines and styles that not only enhance the natural beauty of curls but also promote hair health.